The Never Ending Realm

Suikoden Review (PS1) By Samuel Rivera

Home
About the Editors
Top 10 RPGs
Reviews
News and Articles
Mailbag
Favorite Links
Contact Us
Fan Fictions
Message Boards
Previews

 

Old Classic Still Has Some Fire Left In It

 

Suikoden wasn’t the PS1’s first RPG but for all intent and purposes it should have. Beyond the Beyond was the title that beat Suikoden out of the gates, and it was a god awful title that did nothing to bring the genre into the 32 bit era.  Suikoden however would become the first great RPG title in the system, and it was the title that paved the way for a series spanning more that 5 titles.

            Irony would have it that Suikoden would also fail to bring the genre into the 32 bit era, (Something that FFVII would later get credit for) Suikoden was more of an ode to the 16 bit era, a 2-D RPG held back by simplistic conventions of the era, but polished to perfection, in a way that it gives let’s say FFVI and the Lunar games a run for their money, but falls short when compared the behemoth’s of the 32-Bit era.

            Today in 2007 the game is still worthy of a play if only to appreciate the subtle but yet beautiful artwork, and the excellently told story, of 108 stars (characters).

 

Opens the Show for the 32-bit Era RPG’s But Looks 16-Bit All The Way

 

            Suikoden looks 16 bit, so instead of comparing it to games like FFVII and Grandia, it would be fairer for the game to be compared to games like Chrono Trigger and FFVI. Art Work wise the game does not match the brilliance of those fine titles, but as far as 2-D graphics go this is game is top of the class in terms of its technical mastery over the art. Large 2-D sprites accompany large colorful words. The design while almost flawless leaves something to be desired in the creative department, where the game doesn’t take enough risks to break from the mold. It’s a shame because this is also true for the rest of the games in the series. While the mishaps of the rest of the series won’t influence on the score of Suikoden, Konami has always kept the series from breaking out of its traditional art style, which is why the series while long and good, has never reached a quality level to match Final Fantasy games.

            That the game does not imitate the FF series is perhaps strength in some ways like storytelling and game play, but artistically the games does not break any new ground, and Sega CD, Genesis, and SNES elite RPGs have the game beat on that department.

 

Interesting Story Not Quite An Award Winner but Good Nonetheless

 

Suikoden won’t win any literary awards and in fact the Series peak in this category came in the 3rd Installment which broke all rules of convention to deliver a truly riveting moral plot that thought players a lesson about War and Hate, but Suikoden stays fairly simple, a forgivable trait for pre FFVII RPGs, but still when you consider that FFVI was deliver and Epic drama tour de force two years earlier, it makes you question why Konami didn’t went for all the marbles with its first 32 bit RPG. The idea of building your own castle with your own Army is compelling, but it wasn’t fleshed out as much as it could have been, still a pretty compelling tale, provided you haven’t played any other game in the series. 

Suikoden basically provides a straightforward story that deals with war and in an epic medieval setting, nothing much happens here that is out of the ordinary, but it is a well told story.

Plays Old-School With a Twist

 

            It might sound like I am being tough on the game on the other departments and well…I am going to come down pretty hard on the game on this one too, besides the 108 character collect-a-thon the game did not do much to evolve the genre in fact dare I say Chrono Trigger and FFVI did more to push the genre forward than Suikoden did. Battles are sometimes challenging, the big army battles play more or less like a Strategy RPG, as long as you level up you will be fine.

 

Sounds 16 bit Too

 

The compositions are actually very good; however the aural quality is not. If it looks like a 16 bit RPG and plays like one it’s safe to say that it will also sound like one, in fact the deeper I got into the game I began to wonder whether this game was originally intended to be a SNES RPG.

 

Suikoden The Old School Of The 32 Bit Era

 

If  you walk into Suikoden expecting a full blown 32 bit RPG you will be disappointed, Wild Arms the next big RPG at that time actually made bigger strides to that end. However if you walk into the game looking for a polished 2-D traditional RPG then you will be delighted to find Suikoden is one of the better 2-D RPGs you can play.

 

Gameplay: 8.0- Polished. Battles require a degree of strategy, but still sticks to the tried and true  “level up a ton” in order to succeed in the game, collecting 108 characters was a refreshing diversion at the time of the game’s release.

 

Graphics:  7.0- Great Looking 2-D RPG, however I still think some SNES and Sega CD RPGs look better. Plus Along came Wild Arms in 1997 and Alundra in 1998, both games looked much better.

 

Music: 7.5- Once again the compositions are very good, but the aural quality doesn’t match up, and it’s probably the bottom of the barrel of its era in the category only Shadow Madness probably sounds worst.

 

Story: 8.0- It fares better here than in other categories, and in an RPG the story is the main, Suikoden provides an engrossing tale for start to finish even if it isn’t a memorable one.

 

Addictiveness: 6.0- As with most RPGs of this ilk, this is a once and you are done deal, however hardcore “completists” will find the quest to find 108 character compelling.

 

Overall: 7.5- One of the better 2-D RPGs, you can play, and one of the hardest to find these days, in the series only Suikoden 2 is rarer, Suikoden had the misfortune of coming around in the era of the Grandia’s, FFVII’s and Panzer Dragoon Saga’s, when it clearly seemed it was stuck in the era of the Chrono Triggers and FFVI’s.

 

2003-2008 RicanSaiyan. All works here are copyrighted by their authors.